Every remodel reaches a moment like this. The wall is open and there’s a pipe where nobody expected one. The window you chose is back-ordered eight weeks. The crew needs an answer by tomorrow morning.
That’s the moment when homeowners make their most expensive decisions: tired, rushed, standing in a half-finished room, often without a price in front of them.
You can’t prevent every surprise on a remodeling project. Old houses especially have a way of hiding things. But you can take most of the pressure out of those moments by settling two things before work starts: how changes will be handled, and when your decisions are due.
Part 1: Change orders
A change order is a written agreement to change the work after the contract is signed. It might add work, remove work or substitute one thing for another. Changes happen on almost every project, for three main reasons:
- You change your mind. You decide to add recessed lights, or move the island six inches.
- Something unexpected turns up. Rot behind the shower wall, wiring that doesn’t meet code, framing that isn’t where the plans assumed.
- Something isn’t available. A product is discontinued or delayed, and a substitute is needed.
None of these are anyone’s fault. The trouble comes when changes are handled loosely: a quick “sure, go ahead” in the driveway, with the cost settled weeks later on the final invoice.
What a good change order includes
- A clear description of the work being added, removed or changed
- The cost, or the credit, stated as a number
- Any effect on the schedule
- Signatures from both you and the contractor, before the changed work proceeds
That last point matters most. A price agreed after the work is done isn’t a negotiation; it’s a bill.
Questions to settle before you sign the contract
How are changes priced? At a fixed price for each change, or at cost plus a markup? What is the markup?
Is there a fee for processing a change? Some contractors charge an administrative fee per change order. That’s reasonable if you know about it in advance.
How are unforeseen conditions handled? Ask how the contractor will tell you when they find something unexpected, and whether work stops until you approve the fix.
What happens to the schedule? Changes often add time as well as money. Ask how that’s documented.
A habit that saves money
When a change comes up mid-project, ask for the price before saying yes. Even a rough number in writing, a text or an email, is far better than none. If a decision truly can’t wait, agree on a not-to-exceed amount and have it written down.
Part 2: The selection schedule
The second source of pressure is selections: the tile, faucets, cabinet hardware, paint colors, light fixtures, flooring and dozens of other choices a remodel requires.
Every one of those items has a deadline, whether or not anyone says so out loud. The cabinets have to be ordered weeks or months before they’re installed. The plumbing fixtures may need to be on site before the walls are closed, because the rough plumbing depends on them. The tile has to arrive before the tile setter does.
When selections are made late, a few things tend to happen:
- The crew waits, and the schedule slips.
- You choose whatever is in stock rather than what you wanted.
- Rush shipping and reorders add cost.
- Decisions get made without checking them against the budget or the allowance.
Ask for a selection list with dates
Before work starts, ask your contractor for a list of every selection you’ll need to make and the date each one is due. A good contractor will either have one or be glad to put one together.
Then work backward. Some choices, like cabinets and windows, have long lead times and need to be made early. Others, like paint colors, can wait. Knowing which is which lets you spread the decisions out instead of facing a dozen at once.
Make the decisions before the deadline
Treat each deadline as the latest possible day, not the target. Visit showrooms early. Bring home samples. Look at the tile next to the cabinet door and the countertop sample before anything is ordered. Decisions made at home, with time to think, are almost always better and cheaper than decisions made in a hurry on site.
Calmer, not perfect
Homeowners who start a project with a clear change-order process and a selection schedule don’t have perfect remodels. Nobody does. But they tend to have calmer ones, with fewer surprises on the final invoice and fewer decisions they regret.
Want more questions like this?
Change orders and selection deadlines are questions 3 and 5 on my free remodeling checklist, a one-page list of the conversations to have before you sign anything.
New here? Get the free checklist:
Already have it? Before You Remodel goes further: the full planning guide, homeowner questionnaire and 48-page project log.